How grain from occupied Crimea gets to Yemen

26 December 2024 7 minutes Author: Cyber Witcher

The article reveals scandalous details about the export of grain from the occupied Crimea to Yemen. You will learn how a Russian-flagged ship violated international norms by hiding its route, and why these actions have outraged Ukraine. Read on to understand how such schemes threaten sanctions and international security.

  • Disclaimer: This article is prepared for informational purposes only. All information presented in the material is based on open sources and is not intended to accuse any individuals or organizations.

What is happening?

Ukraine has expressed outrage over a second clandestine export operation, when a Russian-flagged ship transported grain from a port in the occupied Crimea to Houthi-controlled Yemen. The port is under Western sanctions.

Such actions, which Ukraine calls “grain theft” through the occupied territories, have become frequent since the start of Russia’s full-scale invasion. Dozens of ships deliver grain from Crimean ports to Syria, Iran and other countries.

Ukraine has long called on ports to refuse to accept such cargoes if their illegal origin is known. The issue has also been repeatedly raised with the International Maritime Organization.

According to the latest case, the Zafar (IMO: 9720263) loaded grain in Sevastopol in early October and arrived at the port of Salif in Yemen in mid-November. Before reaching its final destination, the vessel stopped in Djibouti, where it is routinely inspected by the United Nations Verification and Inspection Mechanism (UNVIM) for Yemen.

Satellite and ship tracking data confirm that the vessel was in Djibouti in early November and then continued on its route to Yemen. However, it is not known whether the vessel underwent an official inspection.

Left: AIS data shows Zafar in Djibouti on November 3. The satellite image shows the vessel in the same position as the AIS signal, matching the characteristics and measurements of Zafar.

Even if the Zafar had received UNVIM clearance, its operations would remain illegal because its port of origin, occupied Crimea, is under international sanctions. UNVIM’s primary mission is to facilitate the movement of commercial cargo to Yemeni ports that are not controlled by the government, as well as to enforce the UN arms embargo.

It is possible that the Zafar did not inform UNVIM of the true origin of the cargo. The vessel had switched off its Automated Identification System (AIS), concealing its presence in the port of Sevastopol, and this information was only revealed through satellite imagery. To verify its origin, the vessel would have had to provide a bill of lading and a permit from the port of departure, but without access to the documentation it is impossible to determine what information was provided.

The ultimate owner of the Zafar remains unknown, and the ship’s manager has declined to comment on the situation. This only highlights the complexity of monitoring and enforcing international norms in such cases.

The stated scenario raises questions within the UN and UNVIM

Earlier this year, the Zafar made a similar trip, as reported by various sources. Experts noted that grain shipments from occupied Sevastopol, even with UNVIM approval, created a tense situation for the UN. This was happening against the background of the fact that most of the organization’s member states repeatedly voted against Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.

The UN General Assembly adopted a number of resolutions against the annexation of Crimea and the fighting in eastern Ukraine back in 2014. In 2022, after Russia’s full-scale invasion, the UN General Assembly called for the complete withdrawal of Russian troops from the territory of Ukraine. However, General Assembly votes, unlike Security Council resolutions, are only advisory in nature.

The port of Sevastopol is currently under US and UK sanctions, and the terminal where the Zafar docked is under EU sanctions. However, the UN has not imposed sanctions on either the port or Russia.

A Ukrainian Foreign Ministry spokesman said Ukraine was outraged that the Zafar had arrived in Yemen from Crimea, although he declined to comment on UNVIM’s role. He added that Ukraine was continuing its efforts to expose Russia’s illegal movement of Ukrainian grain through occupied territories and ports.

There was no immediate comment from the Russian government or the Russian Foreign Ministry at the time of publication.

It remains unclear where the grain that the Zafar delivered to Yemen was harvested. Farmers in the occupied territories of Ukraine have previously accused Russian forces of confiscating the grain, which was then exported.

Yemen remains one of the world’s poorest countries. A decade of civil war between the internationally recognized government, backed by Saudi Arabia, and the Houthis, backed by Iran, has led to a severe humanitarian crisis. The UN High Commissioner for Refugees says millions of people have been displaced and the country is on the brink of famine.

The grain shipment delivered by the Zafar in November arrived just days before reports emerged that Yemeni mercenaries were fighting alongside Russia in Ukraine. Some Yemenis say they were tricked into traveling to Russia and then forced to fight.

While there is no direct evidence linking the grain shipments to the Yemeni mercenaries’ involvement in the war, Russia has reportedly sought to develop contacts with the Houthis. However, the Pentagon said it had found no significant Houthis support or influence in the war in Ukraine.

The US State Department noted UNVIM’s important role in facilitating the movement of goods and separately condemned the theft of Ukrainian grain, calling it “appalling.”

How Zafar was tracked

The Zafar, a 180-meter bulk carrier, was captured on satellite imagery while loading grain at the port of Sevastopol on October 6. Its Automated Identification System (AIS) transponder was switched off, masking its location from maritime observers and marine tracking data. sites.

Deliberately switching off AIS is generally considered a deceptive shipping practice unless the vessel is in danger.

Zafar pictured in the port of Sevastopol on October 6, 2024.

The Zafar switched off its AIS on 28 September, last seen south of the Kerch Strait between Crimea and Russia. The vessel then visited Sevastopol, as confirmed by satellite images showing the loading of grain. The AIS was only switched on again on 9 October.

According to AIS, the Zafar passed through the Bosphorus Strait on 14 October, then continued its route through the Suez Canal, heading for Djibouti.

Left: The bulk carrier Zafar passes through the Bosphorus Strait on October 14, 2024. Right: The Zafar is pictured in the port of Sevastopol on September 28. Identification features can be seen, including four cream-colored cranes (red boxes) and signs on the ship (blue arrows).

After leaving Djibouti, it sailed to Salif in western Yemen, where satellite images showed the ship unloading on November 13. AIS showed the ship in port at the same time.

Zafar is pictured in Salif on November 13, 2024. Image credit: Planet Labs PBC.

Leaving Salif on November 18, Zafar returned through the Suez Canal, the Bosphorus Strait, and back into the Black Sea.

In the photo, Zafar is heading north through the Bosphorus Strait on November 29.

According to AIS data, at the time of writing, the Zafar was anchored in the Kerch Strait, a waterway between Russia and occupied Crimea. This is the same location where the ship last disappeared from AIS before satellite imagery captured it loading grain at the port of Sevastopol.

Information taken from open sources Bellingcat

Other related articles
Found an error?
If you find an error, take a screenshot and send it to the bot.